About the judges
No adjudicator is allowed to judge (Musicality, Pictures, Drill and Design, Percussion, Drum Majors, and Auxiliary) in a category more than once in a regular season. In summary, each of the five major adjudication areas will all have different judges for each month of the regular season. For example, if a committee member judges Musicality in Division I in September, he/she will not be able to judge that category in October or November. They will move to a different category in the next month. This has been a standard practice of the committee since the inaugural BOTY.
Other than the BOTY Committee Chairs, none of the adjudicators know the final results of the “overall” monthly rankings until they are made public by ESPN and HBCUGameday. Once adjudicators have reviewed videos, they submit scores individually and electronically without group or committee conversation. Any discussion or conversation regarding the rankings must be conducted through our chairs prior to reviewing or scoring the bands.
Auxiliary scores are based on the median or “average” of the combined totals. If the majorettes score 29, the flags 30, and dancers 31, the total auxiliary score is 30. If the dancers score 29 and the flags score 30, the total auxiliary score is 29.5. If a team only has one auxiliary unit that scores 30, their final score is 30. The units with multiple auxiliaries do not get extra points.
Adjudicators (thus far) for the College/HBCU and High School BOTY include:
Dr. Julian White, Florida A&M University, Director of Bands Emeritus
Professor Dowell Taylor, Jackson State University, Director of Bands Emeritus
Professor Lawrence Jackson, Southern University, Director of Bands Emeritus
Professor Melvin Miles, Morgan State University, Director of Bands Emeritus
Professor Richard Lee, Texas Southern University, Director of Bands Emeritus
Professor James Holden, Virginia State University, Director of Bands Emeritus
Dr. Greg Drane, Penn State University, Director of Bands, Bethune Cookman Alumnus
Dr. LaToya Webb, Towson State University, Director of Bands, Norfolk State Alumnus
Present Directors (thus far) for the College/HBCU and High School BOTY include: (Cannot
Adjudicate within their respective division):
Dr. Jorim Reed, Director of Bands Morgan State University
Dr. Julliet Boykins, Director of Bands, Elizabeth City State University
Dr. William Brooks, Director of Bands, Albany State University
Dr. James Oliver, Director of Bands, Alabama State University
Professor Carlton Wright, Director of Bands, Alabama A&M University
Dr. Richard Beckford (High School Chair), Director of Bands, Florida Memorial University
Ms. Shawn Zachery, Auxiliary Director, Prairie View A&M
Ms. Rae Ransome-Coleman, Auxiliary Director, Morehouse College
Ms. Eboni Young, Auxiliary Director, Norfolk State
What’s Next for ESPN Band of the Year?
With just a few months until the final showdown in Atlanta, the 2024 ESPN Band of the Year competition is closer than ever. Each performance now counts as bands refine their shows and push for a spot in the top rankings. The top two Division I bands will compete on December 13 at Mercedes-Benz Stadium, right before the Cricket Celebration Bowl, for the ultimate title.
The Top five band bands at the top of our cumulative rankings in November will all be in the running to come to Atlanta for the BOTY competition. Their ranking position in the polls will be the number one factor in receiving an invitation to Atlanta. However, the BOTY committee can also consider other intangibles as it relates to the selection of the final two bands. The goal for every band is to make it to the Top 5 in November, so they can be a part of the conversation to come to Atlanta.
“This season’s BOTY promises to be one of the best yet,” said Professor Dowell Taylor, Jackson State University Director Emeritus and ESPN BOTY Chair. “Even at this early stage in the process, the renewed emphasis on the halftime field experience and the overall musical presentation has been phenomenal and very encouraging. Because most bands are so very close in the ratings. this will be a grueling process and labor of love for the adjudicators. And this is what it’s all about.”
How to Stay Updated
To catch all the action, follow the ESPN Band of the Year competition through HBCU Gameday and ESPN platforms, where you’ll find monthly updates and exclusive behind-the-scenes content. Every performance counts in this season-long journey, and with the latest October rankings setting the stage, the path to the championship is heating up.
Will North Carolina A&T maintain its top spot and defend its title as the top HBCU band, or will challengers like Florida A&M and Jackson State find a way to rise above? Stay tuned as the ESPN Band of the Year competition unfolds and the journey to Atlanta intensifies.