The 2018 Harlon Hill Trophy will be presented on December 14, 2018. For the second year in a row, Bowie State Quarterback Amir Hall is a finalist for the trophy, which is annually awarded to Division II’s Most Outstanding Player. Hall finished fifth in voting last year, behind (in order) Texas A&M-Commerce Quarterback Luis Perez (winner), Gannon Running Back Marc Jones, Slippery Rock Defensive Lineman Marcus Martin, and Shepherd Quarterback Connor Jessop.
While Hall’s performance last year was
2017(11 games): 249 completions of 381 attempts, 3,519 passing yards, 41 touchdowns, 4 interceptions, 406 rushing yards, 8 rushing touchdowns
2018 (13 games): 4,152 passing yards, 31 passing touchdowns, 10 interceptions, 445 rushing yards, 7 touchdowns
Bowie State’s offensive philosophy really leaned heavily on Hall this year given that the running game wasn’t as potent as last year. The reliance on Hall resulted in him leading Division II in total offense and second in total offense per game. Two other finalists have over 4000 yards in total offense: QB Isaac Harker of Colorado Mines and QB Jayru Campbell of Ferris State.
So how does this voting thing work?
The award is presented the night before the National Championship game. The Harlon Hill Trophy is voted on by Sports Information Directors across the country. That means the CIAA (and SIAC) SIDs will have a seat at the table when it comes to voting for the winner. Past history has shown that voters from a regional and national level don’t pay much attention to the conference or seem willing to support more visible teams. We’ve already seen this year:
Valdosta State QB Rogan Wells selected as
Amir Hall left off of the AFCA All-America team. It’s the second straight year that the star QB was left off this team. AFCA’s voters opted to recognize Travis Tarnowski of Ashland as a 2nd team quarterback last year. This year, that voting block selected Layton Rabb of Midwestern State as the
Another point of contention is that other CIAA standouts are ignored on that national stage. A really good example would be Virginia Union’s RB Tabyus Taylor being left off the AFCA list. Taylor finished tops in the country in all-purpose yards this year despite only having 61 return yards (and by the way that return ended up as a touchdown) and was second in scoring by a non-quarterback. Last year’s CIAA Player of the Year, Virginia State’s RB Trenton Cannon also lead the country in all-purpose yards and scoring, and was also left off of AFCA’s list.
What about the History of Harlon Hill winners?
It is good to know the history of Harlon Hill winners when comparing what Hall has done. Fifty percent (16 of 32) winners have been QBs. QBs have won the award six of the last eight years. Here is a history of the last eight years (stats are before the national championship game of the respective year):
2017: QB Luis Perez, TAMU-Commerce: 4,678 passing yards, 44 touchdowns
2016; QB Justin Dvorak, Colorado School of Mines: 4,584 passing yards, 53 passing touchdowns, 358 rushing yards, 8 touchdowns
2015: QB Jason Vander Laan, Ferris State: 2626 passing yards, 27 passing touchdowns, 1542 rushing yards, 24 scores, 7 interceptions, 3 lost fumbles
2014: QB Jason Vander Laan, Ferris State: 2381 passing yards, 30 touchdowns, 1466 rushing touchdowns, 20 touchdowns, 7 interceptions, 4 lost fumbles
2013: RB Franklyn Quiteh, Bloomsburg: 2195 rushing touchdowns, 29 rushing touchdowns
2012: QB Zach Zulli, Shippensburg: 4747 passing yards, 54 passing touchdowns, 2 rushing touchdowns
2011: RB Jonas Randolph, Mars Hill: 2,170 rushing yards
2010: Eric Czerniewski, Central Missouri: 5207 passing yards, 46 passing touchdowns
2009: Joique Bell, Wayne State: 2084 rushing yards, 29 rushing touchdowns, 293 receiving yards, 3 receiving touchdowns
The Real Threats
While there are nine finalists from the four Super Regions, I think there are only six threats to win the trophy outside of Hall. Here is a comprehensive view of who I think is his competition (games through December 9, 2018):
QB Jayru Campbell, Ferris State (14 games): 2832 passing yards, 26 passing touchdowns, 5 Interceptions, 1338 rushing yards, 20 touchdowns, 3 Lost Fumbles, 1 receiving touchdown.
QB Isaac Harker, Colorado School of Mines(12 games): 3858 passing yards, 39 passing touchdowns, 12 interceptions, 142 rushing yards, 3 rushing touchdowns
QB Rogan Wells, Valdosta State (13 games): 2726 passing yards, 33 passing touchdowns, 4 interceptions, 821 rushing yards, 11 rushing touchdowns
RB Jaleel McLaughlin, Notre Dame College (14 games): 2421 rushing yards, 79 receiving yards, 19 total touchdowns
RB Gabriel Watson, Sioux Falls (11 games) : 1957 rushing yards, 29 receiving yards, 26 rushing touchdowns
DL Markus Jones, Angelo State (12 games): 51 tackles, 36.5 tackles for loss, 17.5 sacks
Why does Hall deserve to win the Harlon Hill award?
As a reference point: Hall actually lead the country in total offense at the end of last year’s regular
McLaughlin has rushed 378 times this year. The rushing attempts
Where will Hall finish?
Hall most certainly has a case to win the award outright. Keep in mind that a relatively early playoff exit has not kept a player from winning the award. Zulli’s win in 2012 came after being unceremoniously dumped out the second round by national runner up Winston-Salem State. Only two players that I can recall (Washburn (Kansas) QB Dane Simoneau in 2011 and West Liberty State QB Zach Amedro in 2009) have been finalists for the Trophy and lead the country in total offense but didn’t win the overall award. I suspect Hall’s top two challengers will be Campbell and McLaughlin. Anything less than a top three finish would be very disappointing for the CIAA’s all-time leading scorer and passer. A finish higher than fifth would be the closest a CIAA player has come to ever winning the award, but may leave us wondering: What does it take for the CIAA to have a player win the Harlon Hill Trophy?